Mahi-Mahi in East Hampton & Montauk: The Colorful Offshore Favorite

Mahi-mahi (Coryphaena hippurus), also known as dolphin fish or dorado, are one of the most exciting and visually striking fish found in the offshore waters of East Hampton and Montauk. Known for their dazzling colors, acrobatic fights, and delicious, mild-flavored meat, mahi-mahi are a favorite target for offshore anglers looking for fast action and a quality catch.

How We Catch Them

Mahi-mahi are aggressive feeders and can be caught using a variety of methods, including:

• Trolling with small ballyhoo, cedar plugs, squid skirts, and daisy chains, often near floating debris or weed lines where mahi congregate.

• Casting & Live Baiting with live pilchards, sardines, or cut bait when a school is located, often resulting in a frenzy of action.

• Jigging & Popping with small jigs or topwater plugs, especially when mahi are actively feeding near the surface.

Mahi-mahi are known for their aerial displays and rapid directional changes, making them an exciting challenge for anglers. They are commonly found near floating objects, weed lines, or buoys, where they feed on small baitfish and crustaceans.

Migration Patterns

Mahi-mahi are a warm-water species that migrate with ocean currents and temperature breaks. They begin showing up in the offshore waters off Montauk and East Hampton in late spring and summer, with peak fishing from July through September. They are typically found in the same areas as tuna, particularly in the Canyons, The Dip, and temperature breaks near the Gulf Stream, where warm waters attract schools of baitfish.

The Mahi-Mahi Fishery

Mahi-mahi are a fast-growing, highly sustainable species, making them an excellent target for both recreational and commercial fisheries. They reproduce quickly, and their stocks remain strong in the Atlantic. In Montauk, mahi-mahi are highly valued for their mild, slightly sweet meat, making them perfect for grilling, tacos, ceviche, or pan-searing.

With their electrifying colors, high-energy fights, and superb eating quality, mahi-mahi are one of the most exciting offshore species to target off the East End. Whether trolling along weed lines or casting into a frenzied school, landing a mahi is an unforgettable experience for any offshore angler.